Holistic approach to feeding raw

Raw feeding is becoming more and more common and we get questions about it all the time. I’m a strong supporter of feeding a raw diet; my own dogs were weaned to raw, my cat was switched to raw at a year of age, and I encourage my clients to consider feeding a raw diet to their animals. Most animals will do very well on a raw diet of meat, bone, organ meat and vegetables.

However, there are some important considerations when it comes to feeding raw.

Here’s what you need to know …

Holistic Approach To Feeding Raw

#1 Support is crucial

If your vet isn’t supportive, you need to educate yourself about balancing a raw diet and the possible issues involved in a transition to raw feeding. There are books and support groups. Many raw food manufacturers have extensive information on their websites. The Carnivora site is particularly good. If your vet is not supportive, raw feeding will be blamed for every illness and digestive upset, and you’ll be pressured to use treatments which actually upset the balance of the digestive system, such as antibiotics and metronidazole. If your dog has a chronic disease, I wouldn’t suggest switching to raw without the support of a vet.

You need to feel comfortable with what you’re doing, and dealing with a chronic disease requires additional considerations.

#2 Diets must be varied

A single protein source isn’t a good idea, as different meats have different nutrient profiles. The raw diet should contain meat, bone, fat and muscle meat in the proportions found in a lean animal. This can be a bit hard to determine, as our commercially bred meat animals are much fatter than prey animals would be. I can’t comment meaningfully on the balance of these diets, as no indication is given of relative quantities of components. There are a few nutritionists that work with raw feeders; if you chose to assemble a raw diet from animal parts, it is ideal to work with a nutritionist to ensure that the diet, over time, will be balanced.

The raw diet should contain meat, bone, fat and muscle meat in the proportions found in a lean animal.

This is one of the main criticisms of raw diets by vets; all too often people are feeding one type of meat part as the major (or only) diet component. I feed a complete and balanced ground raw diet, rotating between three different protein sources, plus occasional whole animal parts.

#3 Balance is important

Calcium to phosphorus ratio must be maintained in an appropriate range. Please refer to my ATV discussion for more information on this. People can, and do, create serious problems in growing pups by over supplementing or under supplementing calcium in home prepared diets. Adult dogs are less affected by calcium:phosphorus imbalances, but over time adults can develop problems as well, so do pay attention to this aspect of the diet.

[Related] You don’t need a science degree to figure out the balance. Find out how here.

#4 Transition should be gradual

It is understandable to want to get your animal switched to the best possible diet as quickly as possible. However, animals that have been eating kibble or canned food have adjusted to digesting those foods. You have to switch slowly, introducing the raw food in small meals separate from the processed diet. You will gradually increase the size of the raw meal while decreasing the size of the other meals, eventually replacing the processed food meals, one at a time, with raw food meals, then eliminating the extra meal.

#5 Some animals need help to digest raw

Processing begins the digestion process, so processed foods require less enzymatic action from the dog for digestion. Of course, processed foods also contain more inflammatory free radicals because of processing, so there is a negative side to their predigested state! Some dogs will digest their food better if digestive enzymes are added to the food, or if the food is lightly cooked.

Of course, whole bones should not be cooked, but foods with very finely ground bones can be safely cooked lightly. Over time, most animals will increase their digestive enzyme production, and be able to digest raw. However, old or convalescent animals sometimes develop an aversion to raw, or lose weight eating raw. In such cases, addition of enzymes, or gentle cooking, will often help sort out the problem.

#6 Supplements may be needed

  • Digestive enzymes: As discussed above, digestive enzymes may be helpful in the transition period. Some animals maintain condition and appetite better if they receive digestive enzymes in their food at every meal. I like the product Aunt Jeni’s Enhance Digestive Aid (AJEDA), as it contains not only digestive enzymes, but probiotics and soothing herbs.
  • Probiotics: Probiotics help maintain a normal balance of bacteria in the digestive tract. All animals that receive antimicrobials like antibiotics or metronidazole, should receive probiotics during treatment and for a week after treatment. Please try not to give antimicrobials for digestive upsets. Of course an animal with loose stools has abnormal bacteria – that doesn’t mean that the answer is to kill off all the bacteria, normal and abnormal. That approach increases the growth of resistant organisms, and has high potential for side effects. You want to work with the body to restore health, not use drugs with a list of side effects as long as your arm. The process of diet change can also unbalance the normal intestinal bacteria, so I suggest probiotics and digestive enzymes for all animals transitioning to raw.
  • Herbs: Soothing herbs, such as slippery elm, marshmallow root and peppermint found in AJEDA, may be helpful during the raw transition as well. There are some really good ones here.
  • Omega fatty acids: Many raw diets are low in omega fatty acids such as those found in raw fish or krill oil.
  • Vitamin and mineral supplements: The nutrient content of food is related to the way it was raised. If you are feeding only organically raised animals and vegetables, raised on soils that are sustainably supplemented with trace minerals, you have no concerns. Most animals will benefit from a whole foods supplement formulated to complement raw diets. It is important to avoid synthetic supplements, as they can actually be pro-inflammatory. The whole foods supplements are more expensive, but well worth it.

#7 Vegetables may be helpful

Vegetables, especially green leafy vegetables, allow us to manipulate the fat and protein content of the diet, as well as introducing a good source of natural vitamins and minerals.

There is some controversy among the raw feeding community as to whether vegetables are an appropriate part of a raw diet. Some claim that canids in the wild do not eat the stomach contents of their prey, so vegetables are inappropriate. While it is probably true that wolves do not the entire contents of large herbivore stomachs, research has shown that foxes and wolves eat mice and rabbits in their entirety.

In addition, these prey animals are much less fatty than the commercially raised meat we provide. Vegetables, especially green leafy vegetables, allow us to manipulate the fat and protein content of the diet, as well as introducing a good source of natural vitamins and minerals.

#8 Animals with specific health concerns can be fed a raw diet

  • Puppies: Puppies can be weaned to a ground raw diet suitable for adult dogs. Puppies can receive a raw diet based on animal parts as well, taking care to ensure that there is variety in the diet, and that the calcium:phosphorus ratio is appropriate. If you have support from an experienced naturally rearing breeder as regards rearing a pup on animal parts, go for it. Otherwise, I would choose one of the balanced ground raw diets to ensure an appropriate Ca:P ratio.
  • Kidney disease: Most dogs with kidney disease can continue to eat a raw diet. In kidney disease, a moderate decrease in the protein may be helpful; this can be done by introducing shredded or steamed leafy vegetables to the diet.
  • Pancreatitis: Many dogs with pancreatitis can be successfully switched to raw. Ideally, consult with a veterinary nutritionist to ensure that the fat level is appropriate for your dog. In most cases, a combination of lean meats and increased leafy vegetables can create an appropriate diet.

[Related] Age matters … but it also doesn’t. Here’s how to transition your senior dog to raw.

#9 Homeopathy can help

There are many remedies that can be useful for digestive upsets. I discussed this at length in an Ask the Vet post. If symptomatic treatment is not helpful, your animal would likely benefit from a constitutional approach with a veterinary homeopath, to choose the most appropriate remedy for them.

A Holistic Approach To Feeding Raw

After The Transition

As you transition to raw feeding, you’ll notice changes in your dog.

  1. Drinking: Most dogs drink a lot less; some rarely drink at all. If your dog is elderly, you may want to add extra water to the raw meals to ensure that they take in enough water.
  2. Stools: Usually, if you have transitioned gradually, and supported the dog’s digestive tract with supplemental enzymes, probiotics, and soothing herbs, you will see a much firmer stool. If your diet is very high in bone, the stool may be white or ashy looking, and may be very hard. This probably means that you are feeding a little too much bone. I know this sounds disgusting, but you can learn a lot by prodding apart your dog’s stool, to see if it is too hard. Very hard stools can be uncomfortable to pass. If your dog routinely produces very hard stools, you should increase their fluid intake and evaluate the quantity of bone in their diet. Fiber can be helpful to regulate stool quality; both stools that are too soft and too hard will respond to the addition of fiber in the diet. Pumpkin is a good source of fiber; the dose ranges from ½ teaspoon to ¼ cup per meal depending on the dog’s size.
  3. Energy: Dogs that are eating raw food seem to have better focus as well as more energy.
  4. Skin and Coat: Most skin problems decrease, and coat quality improves.

However, raw food is not a cure all! If your dog still has skin and coat problems, you should pursue their cause and treatment with a holistic vet.

I hope this helps address some of the concerns about the holistic approach to feeding raw. Good luck!

Regards,
Sara